This is an old revision of the document!
xro's note on Camping/Tent Rope Tensioners
(german: Seilspanner)
Recently for CCCamp2023, I wanted to upgrade my new tent with fancy cord and spanners and thus, inadvertently, came to test and compare a few. Here's what I learned.
rope tensioners - the 4 types
The four types of tensioners I tested.
- classic 3 hole triangle (metallic)
- modern 3 hole straight (black)
- thread-able-in-after-the-fact with 2 small and one big hole (red)
- minimalistic bent 2-hole (red)
The tensioners were rated according to performance in the following applications:
- packing-size / space needed in your packed tent
- how well it holds tension under force
- how good it looks
- ease of slackening or tensioning the line
rope tensioner - the classic 3 hole triangle
TLDR: this is the best tensioner you can buy. The design is old but still the best.
discipline | verdict |
---|---|
packing-size | as small as other smallest. lightweight and durable in aluminium. |
holding tension | very very well |
looks | classic |
ease of slackening/tensioning | very easy |
big Chinese aluminium tensioner with big hole
Recommended use, rope around big bend
Recommended use, rope around small bend
used like a triangle 3 hole
Alternate use as winch
Chinese aluminium tensioner with 2 holes and bent shape
- very much depends on being around small bend. Wont work as well around trees or lamp posts, etc
discipline | verdict |
---|---|
packing-size | |
holding tension | |
looks | |
ease of slackening/tensioning |
tensioning rope with rope
TODO
discipline | verdict |
---|---|
packing-size | unbeatable as you have only rope |
holding tension | |
looks | |
ease of slackening/tensioning |
Connecting/fixing rope to tent
My new Quechua tent shipped with tent-rope that had oval toggle-buttons (oblong buttons; Knebelknöpfe) on one end.
The idea being that the rope is easy to remove fr
discipline | verdict |
---|---|
packing-size | |
holding tension | |
looks | |
ease of slackening/tensioning |
om the loops mounted on the tent.
I liked the idea and imitated it by buying some of these toggle-buttons online. I think they introduced it because
- they can market it as more easy, as people don't have to tie a know
- makes the tent better packable, as ropes don't get entangled during the folding process
- when tying down the tent is optional, the lines are also optional
In hindsight however, I prefer the rope that is permanently tied to the tent (e.g. with a Palstek), because
- it's quicker to deploy. The rope is already there
- I always tie down the tent
- the toggle-button can fall out while you try to fix the line if you slacken it for a moment, which is quite inconvenient